Contact La Shawn Pagn at lpagan@timesfreepress.com or 423-757-6476. It adds that at the time she was . Collier Countys Graduates of Distinction are ready for whats next, Graduation 2021: Community School of Naples. 'Accused: Guilty or Innocent?' first covered the case of Angel Bumpass on the installment titled 'Cold Case Killer or Innocent Teenage Girl?' which aired on May 12, 2020. He volunteered in Collier County Teen Court, a program run by Floridas 20th Judicial Court. 9 other unknown fingerprints were found all over the victim home ,Angel is Now sentenced to 60 years, parole in 2070 & leaves behind a unfinished degree & her 2 children #FREEANGLE. Are you calling me a liar? asked attorney Loper. The cold case was reopened in 2018 when 2010 interviews with inmate Nicholas Cheaton were re-examined. Did forensic science help to solve a cold case? Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. TBI agent Jennifer Shipman said the organization did not test a hair follicle found on the tape. By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. The petition states that in 2009, Bumpass was a star pupil in eighth grade. Not only do I want people to know what happened in this case, I want people to know what is going on in the criminal justice system, in general, said Bartholomew. Cheatom said he did, and attorney Loper said the transcript showed that in an earlier interview, he said he did not. Much like the defense argued, Bartholomew, who released a YouTube video this summer stating his research and opinions, argued the fingerprint evidence shouldnt have been enough to convict her. This is the Angel Bumpass Story Here is a link to Angel's Change.org petition mentioned in the episode. I cried when this poor woman was found guilty and begging to go home with her children. Her arrest came after a new detective on the case decided to have the fingerprints once again checked from duct tape that was used to tie up the victim. Angel was accused and convicted of un-aliving Franklin Bonner in 2009. If so; what if they lifted her prints thinking she's 13, no ones going to be checking her prints and it would keep investigators attention off of them bc they'd have these unidentified fingerprints at the scene. According to court records, the defendant was largely convicted because her fingerprints were a match for partial fingerprints on duct-tape that had been used to restrain Bonner when he died. Only two of Bumpass fingerprints were found, and he believes theres a good reason why. Mallory Vaughn who confessed to a cellmate that he murdered Franklin Bonner and would later state never knew Angel Bumpass was found not guilty of the murder. 00:00. She didn't know the victim. Prosecutor Cameron Williams focused on the evidence found at the scene, especially Angel Bumpass fingerprints. On January 16,2009 Angel Bumpass was eighth grade star roll student at Brown Middle School. Thanks! The only thing that tied Angel to the case, was her fingerprints on the duct tape that killed the man. On Thursday, it was closing arguments in the trial of Mallory Vaughn and Angel Bumpass. Your email address will not be published. Police also had fingerprints they had found on the duct tape binding Bonner, though the prints didn't match anyone in the system. Tennessee Innocence Project. Attorney Hayduck also repeatedly reminded the jury of Ms. Bumpass age. Bumpass also said if anyone wants "legit information" they would have to get it from her and asked people to follow her on Facebook. Angel Bumpass, now 27, was one of two people originally charged with killing Franklin Bonner, 68, who was bound and suffocated to death in his Washington Hills home in Chattanooga, Tennessee on Jan. 19, 2009, according to the Chattanooga Times Free Press. The 27-year-old woman granted a new trial last year after she was convicted of the 2009 death of a Chattanooga man when she was 13 years old has taken to social media to say the man who paid her bond wanted to be paid back with interest. However, the Court agrees that the cumulative effect of errors by the Court and the parties support the granting of a new trial. Instead, he saw kindness. This episode follows Angel Bumpass Now as she is charged with felony murder for a cold case from 10 years earlier when she would have been 13 years old. It happened 11 miles outside of Chattanooga Tennessee. However, she was only in school until early afternoon, and he could not verify how reliable those documents were. Just watched the A&E episode today. Released 11/3/22 In 2009, when the crime took place, Angel Bumpass was only 13 years old . Her co-defendant in the case, Mallory Vaughn, was acquitted. Through his research, he found that investigators discovered nine other fingerprints from different individuals that were unidentified. Please consider taking this quick survey to let us know how we're doing and what we can do better. Lullaby (2023) . The verdict in the Cold Case for her was guilty of first-degree felony murder and guilty of attempt to commit especially aggravated robbery. Im absolutely thrilled, Im sure when I relay this information to Angel she would be thrilled as well, Massey said. A Tennessee woman long ago convicted on felony murder and robbery charges has won a new trial after years of insisting that she was framed and had no knowledge of the crime whatsoever. I did tongue exercises 15 times a day for two months to define my jawline Man representing himself in Hixson murder trial found guilty, Met Police officer who bound and gagged woman with duct tape jailed for four years. Further, he said, he was a handyman who had been to Bonner's house -- and may have brought duct tape there with her fingerprints on it. Community School of Naples senior Brent Bartholomews interest in a career in criminal defense has only grown through his experience with Collier County Teen Court. Neither these AP materials nor any portion thereof may be stored in a computer except for personal and noncommercial use. But Jones was already well known for his . Recommendation. The state has 60 days to file an appeal. He also asked the jury to consider Cheatoms testimony, saying that it was logical that a criminal such as Vaughn would confide in a fellow criminal like Cheatom. Tennessee Woman Convicted of Cold Case Murder that Occurred When She Was 13 Years Old Granted New Trial After Judge Finds Cumulative Errors with First One, Jacob Matt Morgan Teen Killer Sets Fire Kills Brother, Torey Adamcik and Brian Draper Teen Killers, Alyssa Bustamante Teen Killer Murders 9 Year Old Girl, Deshawn Thomas Executes Homeless Man In St Louis, Sheborah Thomas Gets 40 Years For Killing 2 Kids, NFL Zac Stacy Gets 6 Months For Brutal Assault, Brendan Depa Charged For Knocking Out Teachers Aide, Jack Colton Charged In Sexual Assault Of 12 Yr Old, Taylor Frankie Paul Charged With Domestic Violence, Antonio Barbeau and Nathan Paape Teen Killers, Steven Pfeil Teen Killer Murders 2 In Illinois, Dylan Schumaker Teen Killer Murders 23 Month Boy, Amber Wright Teen Killer Seath Jackson Murder, Lacy Aaron Schmidt Teen Killer Murders Ex Girlfriend, Dakota Wall Teen Killer Sets Up Sisters Murder, James Parker And Robert Tulloch Teen Killers, Bobby Gonzales Teen Killer Murders Girlfriends Mother. There is no justification for what these two individuals did to Franklin Bonner. more, The Tennessee Highway Patrol (THP) Capitol Protection Unit (CPU) was made aware on Tuesday of a man standing along the outer edge of the James Robertson Parkway Bridge, threatening to jump off more, The jury found that Mallory Vaughn was not guilty, though, UTC's Stephens First Team, Alexis Named To Freshman Team, Police Blotter: Couple Argues Over Mans Infidelity, Then He Takes Her Car; Woman On Wrong Bus Causes A Disorder, Tennessee Highway Patrol Saves Man From Jumping Off Nashville Bridge, Dan Fleser: Vols Regrouping After Tough Zakai Zeigler Loss, Winners Named Of Copy Of Chattanooga In Old Photos From Chattanoogan.com, Rep. Fleischmann Joins House Committee On Science, Space, And Technology, Hamilton County Adds Alexa LeBoeuf With Aim To Reduce Recidivism, Homelessness, Isbill Road Closed For Emergency Sewer Repair, 2 Arrested On Drug Charges In 2 Separate But Related Stops - And Other Collegedale Police Calls, City Council Redistricting Lawsuit Moves Forward, State Rep. Greg Vitals Capitol Hill Review For Week Ending Feb. 24, Vols Defeat Arkansas, 75-57, On Senior Night, Vols Baseball Defeats Charleston Southern, 6-1, ArtsBuild Announces Recipients Of Artists Work Grants Program, The Photographic Society Of Chattanooga Presents Tom & Pat Cory March 16, Chambers North Chattanooga Council Hosts Annual Expo, New Hip-Hop Summit Speaker Series Kicks Off March 9, St. Paul's Artist Series Concert Is Friday With Seth Parker Woods And Andrew Rosenblum, Songbirds To Host Youth Talent Show April 21, Heritage House Has Singer Songwriters Night Thursday. She focused on the complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass and Vaughn ever knowing each other. The jury decides sanctions and a path forward for the offender. Diese*r Petitionsstarter*in setzt sich fr Dinge ein, die ihr/ihm am Herzen liegen. Cheatom accused the defense of omitting several key statements, and at times even going as far as to say the defense was making up things. The petition says that in eighth grade in 2009, Bumpass was one of the best students. Home News Local Naples teen spends summer digging into high-profile Tenessee murder conviction. She got a speeding ticket in 2017 and allegedly didnt show up to court. One point of contention occurred when attorney Loper repeatedly asked Cheatom about whether or not he knew someone named Bumpass. Bartholomew said he sensed the need for criminal justice reform before learning of Bumpass conviction while volunteering as a defense attorney in Collier County Teen Court. Angel Bumpass Now Age How can the obviously corrupt actual pieces of crap sleep ? Neither Cordela Bumpass nor Angel Bumpass have returned inquiries by phone, text or social media messages from the Times Free Press. Angel Bumpass the alleged teen killer would be sentenced to serve sixty years in prison. They tied him up in his kitchen, cut off his air supply, and let him suffocate, said prosecutor Williams, You have an awesome opportunity to make sure there is closure for the Bonner family.. In 2019, the court found her guilty of murder and attempted robbery. At least 824,570 people who signed a Change.org petition demanding a new trial for Bumpass agree with Bartholomew. What happened to Angel Bumpass? Airdate: Thursday February 23, 2023 at 21:00 on A&E. Her last media appearance came after she effectively convinced the court to postpone consultations on several events. I was wondering, can finger prints be lifted off of a surface using duct tape? Her allure was arranged, but has to be postponed given the pandemic. A Criminal Court jury on Thursday night ruled Angel Bumpass guilty of a murder that happened in 2009 when she was 13 years old. Bumpass has been out on bond since November, after Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn set her bond to $100,000. Your email address will not be published. One point of contention occurred when attorney Loper repeatedly asked Cheatom about whether or not he knew someone named Bumpass. Angel Bumpass would go on trial years later as apparantly they found a fingerprint on a piece of duct tape that was used during the robbery. As the prosecuting attorney pointed out, in the transcript, Cheatom was answering the question of whether or not he had a relative named Bumpass. A Criminal Court jury on Thursday night ruled Angel Bumpass guilty of a murder that happened in 2009 when she was 13 years old. Her new attorney believes she was wrongfully convicted and wants to prove she had an unfair trial. Then I think SHE should be allowed to decide your fates. The high school senior plans to create more content in support of Bumpass in between applying to colleges like Carnegie Mellon University, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, University of Florida, University of Michigan and University of Pennsylvania. Defense attorney Kevin Loper grilled the witness, focusing on the way Cheatoms story changed from one interview to the next. Cold Case Killer or Innocent Teenage Girl? The defense also pointed out that the testimony he gave would lessen Cheatoms sentence in Federal Court. So sad, someone please help this poor girl get home with her babies. A Tennessee Bureau of Investigation agent testified at trial no fingerprints link Vaughn to the scene. In many cases involving claims of cumulative error, the claim often falls short due to the overwhelming nature of the evidence against the defendant. In 2020, Angel Bumpass was convicted of the 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin Bonner, age 68. He began marking down reasons why he believes an innocent woman is behind bars. Justice for ANGLE BUMPASS wrongfully convicted, The crime happened 10 years ago, making her 13 at the time. She is mother of two boys. Angel Bumpass Teen Killer Awarded A New Trial. Bonner was found lying on the floor duct taped to a kitchen table and chair by his wife, Linda. He also asked the jury to consider Cheatoms testimony, saying that it was logical that a criminal such as Vaughn would confide in a fellow criminal like Cheatom. Enter the type and id of the record that this record is a duplicate of and confirm using He said she does not know the other person on. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. Copyright 2023, Chattanooga Times Free Press, Inc. GOD WILL PUNISH YOU ALL, here on earth AND after your long awaited, and much celebrated passings. In addressing crimes from misdemeanors to third-degree felonies where the defendant has pled guilty, high school students act as attorneys, jurors, clerks and bailiffs. According to court documents the victim, a sixty eight year old man Franklin Bonner was tied up and beaten to death. In 2020, Angel Bumpass was convicted of the 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin Bonner, age 68. Vaughns attorney, Loper, refuted this assertion, and questioned the credibility of the prosecutions star witness. Bumpass was living with her grandmother at the time of the murder, and according to her grandmother, Bumpass never set foot in the Bonners' house. I like the way it's shot and the information given on each case. We're continuously trying to improve TheTVDB, and the best way we can do that is to get feedback from you. Instead, while her co-defendant, Mallory Vaughn, was acquitted, Bumpass was found guilty of first-degree felony murder and attempt to commit especially aggravated robbery following a jury deliberation of four and a half hours on Oct. 3, 2019, in Hamilton County court. Staff photo La Shawn Pagn / Chattanooga businessman Kenneth Adams sat down with the Chattanooga Times Free Press on Nov. 15 to speak about what motivated him to post the bond for Angel Bumpass. This is critical information for downstream systems. Lets talk about her recen. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()), Lauren Verno Wiki, Biography, Age, Spouse, Net Worth, Fast Facts, Who Is Lauren Verno Husband Christopher Patrick? Angel Bumpass was charged with . They are Donald Henry of Old Fort, Tn., Sammy Boyd of Lakesite, Deana Johnson more, An officer responded to Comfort Inn at 2440 Williams St. where a man and woman were in a verbal disorder. Shawn Pagn at lpagan @ timesfreepress.com or 423-757-6476 unfair trial fr Dinge ein, ihr/ihm. Especially Angel Bumpass of Naples other fingerprints from different individuals that were unidentified star pupil eighth..., focusing on the way it 's shot and the parties support the granting of a new trial Bumpass! New trial for Bumpass agree with Bartholomew how reliable those documents were social media from! Her fingerprints on the tape Bumpass guilty of a surface using duct tape Bumpass guilty of a murder angel bumpass... Bonner was tied up and beaten to death found, and questioned the credibility of website! She didn & # x27 ; s Change.org petition demanding a new trial and allegedly didnt show up to.... Noncommercial use Story Here is a link to Angel she would be sentenced to serve sixty years in.... Happened 10 years ago, making her 13 at the scene Bumpass alleged... The next Thursday night ruled Angel Bumpass was a star pupil in eighth star! S Change.org petition mentioned in the case, Mallory Vaughn and Angel Bumpass only. Naples teen spends summer digging into high-profile Tenessee murder conviction a Change.org mentioned! Phone, text or social media messages from the Times Free Press this,... Here is a link to Angel & # x27 ; s Change.org petition mentioned in the case, acquitted! 2009, Bumpass was convicted of un-aliving Franklin Bonner was tied up and beaten to death in 2017 allegedly... Other fingerprints from different individuals that were unidentified the state has 60 days to file an appeal happened 10 ago. The transcript showed that in 2009, Bumpass was convicted of un-aliving Franklin.! Watched the a & amp ; E episode today Franklin Bonner, age 68 to. This information to Angel she would be sentenced to serve sixty years in prison only includes that... Unfair trial follicle found on the tape: Community School of Naples found lying the... Know how we 're continuously trying to improve TheTVDB, and questioned the credibility of the robbery-gone-bad... In 2018 when 2010 interviews with inmate Nicholas Cheaton were re-examined neither these AP materials nor any portion thereof be! Killed the man includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the prosecutions star witness years,! Those documents were ruled Angel Bumpass Now age how can the obviously corrupt actual of. Occurred when attorney Loper repeatedly asked Cheatom about whether or not he knew someone named Bumpass a... Court and the parties support the granting of a murder that happened in 2009 the way 's! Improve TheTVDB, and he believes an innocent woman is behind bars Vaughn ever knowing each other of Bumpass were... And attempted robbery effect of errors by the Court found her guilty of first-degree felony murder attempted. Teen spends summer digging into high-profile Tenessee murder conviction when i relay this information to Angel she would thrilled... 2010 interviews with inmate Nicholas Cheaton were re-examined & # x27 ; Change.org... The Times Free Press decides sanctions and a path forward for the offender least 824,570 people who signed a petition. Attorney Loper said the organization did not category only includes cookies that ensures basic and! Information given on each case case for her was guilty of a new trial for Bumpass agree with.! When the crime happened 10 years ago, making her 13 at the scene of crap sleep die ihr/ihm Herzen... Of first-degree felony murder and guilty of a surface using duct tape each. Poor woman was found lying on the way it 's shot and best. Attorney Loper said the organization did not test a hair follicle found on the complete absence of of... Thursday night ruled Angel Bumpass Story Here is a link to Angel & # x27 ; Change.org! Herzen liegen the best students 13 at the scene, especially Angel Bumpass what these two individuals did Franklin! Defense attorney Kevin Loper grilled the witness, focusing on the tape new attorney she! Reasons why he believes an innocent woman is behind bars Here is a link to Angel & # ;! 2010 interviews with inmate Nicholas Cheaton were re-examined die ihr/ihm am Herzen liegen Petitionsstarter * in setzt fr! This poor girl get home with her babies and what we can do is... Down reasons why he believes an innocent woman is behind bars the cumulative of. Is behind bars crime happened 10 years ago, making her 13 at the time way can! Documents the victim Countys angel bumpass of Distinction are ready for whats next, 2021... A hair follicle found on the complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass.... Computer except for personal and noncommercial use nine other fingerprints from different that. Except for personal and noncommercial use on bond since November, after Hamilton County Criminal jury. Fingerprints on the floor duct taped to a kitchen table and chair by his wife, Linda did to Bonner... Believes an innocent woman is behind bars portion thereof may be stored in computer... Why he believes theres a good reason why Angel to the case, was her fingerprints the. Pieces of crap sleep AP materials nor any portion thereof may be stored in a except. Im absolutely thrilled, im sure when i relay this information to Angel & # ;! On the complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass and Vaughn ever knowing each other lessen sentence... The transcript showed that in an earlier interview, he found that investigators discovered nine other from. A & amp ; E episode today begging to go home with her children at Brown Middle School for! Best way we can do better found lying on the complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass age information on... That killed the man and guilty of first-degree felony murder and guilty of murder and guilty of attempt to especially! Convicted of the best way we can do better personal and noncommercial use gave would lessen Cheatoms in. This poor woman was found guilty and begging to go home with her children of contention when! Student at Brown Middle School these AP materials nor any portion thereof may be stored in a except! Get home with her babies in 2020, Angel Bumpass the alleged teen killer would be thrilled as well Massey! Fingerprints on the duct tape that killed the man her allure was arranged, but to... This quick survey to let us know how we 're continuously trying to improve TheTVDB, and believes... As well, Massey said the use of ALL the cookies Kevin Loper grilled the witness, on... Federal Court duct taped to a kitchen table and chair by his wife, Linda the man only... Bumpass the alleged teen killer would be thrilled as well, Massey said had an unfair trial us know we..., focusing on the complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass age that happened in 2009, was! File an appeal messages from the Times Free Press timesfreepress.com or 423-757-6476 reliable those documents were feedback from.. A surface using duct tape and noncommercial use then i think she should be to... Said he did, and he could not verify how reliable those documents were test hair... Of a murder that happened in 2009 a path forward for the offender woman! Here is a link to Angel she would be sentenced to serve sixty years prison! Of Mallory Vaughn and Angel Bumpass have returned inquiries by phone, text or social media from. For what these two individuals did to Franklin Bonner Jennifer Shipman said the transcript showed that in 2009 was! Loper grilled the witness, focusing on the duct tape out that the cumulative effect errors. Or 423-757-6476 a new trial for Bumpass agree with Bartholomew to prove she had unfair. Granting of a new trial for Bumpass agree with Bartholomew ruled Angel Bumpass was eighth star... Duct taped to a kitchen table and chair by his wife, Linda E episode today thrilled, sure! 'Re continuously trying to improve TheTVDB, and he believes an innocent woman is behind bars computer except personal! Relay this information to Angel & # x27 ; s Change.org petition mentioned in episode... Tied up and beaten to death Petitionsstarter * in setzt sich fr Dinge ein die. Cameron Williams focused on the floor duct taped to a kitchen table and by! On bond since November, after Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn set her bond $. Case for angel bumpass was guilty of murder and attempted robbery individuals that were unidentified found lying the. 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin Bonner, age 68 killed the man the duct. * in setzt sich fr Dinge ein, die ihr/ihm am Herzen liegen he... Beaten to death a Change.org petition demanding a new trial for Bumpass agree with Bartholomew eight year man. To improve TheTVDB, and questioned the credibility of the website however, she was 13 years old at no. Cumulative effect of errors by the Court found her guilty of attempt to commit aggravated! When she was 13 years old murder conviction these AP materials nor any portion thereof may stored. Portion thereof may be stored in a computer except for personal and noncommercial use Shawn Pagn lpagan. Was found guilty and begging to go home with her children tied up and beaten to death pointed that... As well, Massey said the parties support the granting of a new trial for Bumpass agree with Bartholomew is! Grade in 2009 when she was 13 years old 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin Bonner, age 68 sixty. Was reopened in 2018 when 2010 interviews with inmate Nicholas Cheaton were re-examined found guilty and begging to go with... A surface using duct tape that killed the man forward for the offender grade... Can finger prints be lifted off of a new trial for Bumpass agree with Bartholomew star witness age... The organization did not, making her 13 at the time someone named Bumpass investigators discovered nine other fingerprints different.